stats
globeinteractive.com: Making the Business of Life Easier

   Finance globeinvestor   Careers globecareers.workopolis Subscribe to The Globe
The Globe and Mail /globeandmail.com
Home | Business | National | Int'l | Sports | Columnists | The Arts | Tech | Travel | TV | Wheels
space


Search

space
  This site         Tips

  
space
  The Web Google
space
   space



space

  Where to Find It


Breaking News
  Home Page

  Report on Business

  Sports

  Technology

space
Subscribe to The Globe

Shop at our Globe Store


Print Edition
  Front Page

  Report on Business

  National

  International

  Sports

  Arts & Entertainment

  Editorials

  Columnists

   Headline Index

 Other Sections
  Appointments

  Births & Deaths

  Books

  Classifieds

  Comment

  Education

  Environment

  Facts & Arguments

  Focus

  Health

  Obituaries

  Real Estate

  Review

  Science

  Style

  Technology

  Travel

  Wheels

 Leisure
  Cartoon

  Crosswords

  Food & Dining

  Golf

  Horoscopes

  Movies

  Online Personals

  TV Listings/News

 Specials & Series
  All Reports...

space

Services
   Where to Find It
 A quick guide to what's available on the site

 Newspaper
  Advertise

  Corrections

  Customer Service

  Help & Contact Us

  Reprints

  Subscriptions

 Web Site
  Advertise

  E-Mail Newsletters

  Free Headlines

  Globe Store New

  Help & Contact Us

  Make Us Home

  Mobile New

  Press Room

  Privacy Policy

  Terms & Conditions


GiveLife.ca

    

PRINT EDITION
Sidewalk Labs' Toronto project needs more oversight, Auditor-General warns
space
space
By JOSH O'KANE
  
  

Email this article Print this article
Thursday, December 6, 2018 – Page A1

TORONTO -- Ontario's Auditor-General has found that Waterfront Toronto gave Google affiliate Sidewalk Labs preferential treatment in its selection for a partner to build a proposed smart-city community on the city's eastern lakefront, rushing numerous parts of the process with insufficient government oversight.

Infrastructure Minister Monte McNaughton, who oversees the file for the province, promised to take "decisive action" in a matter of days about the the findings in Bonnie Lysyk's annual audit, which recommended the province develop responsible policies to govern the new kind of techdriven community Sidewalk wants to build on the waterfront.

Asked by The Globe and Mail what actions his ministry would take, he declined to speculate except for principles that would guide them: "We're going to ensure that taxpayers get value for money. We will ensure that proper oversight is brought forward.

And that privacy laws are followed to the letter."

The proposed 12-acre community, called Quayside, has come at a time when U.S. technology companies have joined the ranks of the world's most valuable firms. They have also come under increasing scrutiny for their use of consumer data, both in terms of privacy and the potential wealth that could be generated from developing future technology from that data. Sidewalk is a subsidiary of Google parent Alphabet Inc., one of the world's foremost data-driven companies.

Quayside would be filled with sensors - for example, to count pedestrians or test for air quality - to collect information to help build future urban technologies.

Waterfront Toronto, an agency controlled by all three levels of government, announced it had selected Sidewalk Labs as its "innovation and funding partner" for the Quayside neighbourhood in October, 2017. The project has faced criticism from Canadian technology leaders over how it would handle the wide range of data issues that would come with building a neighbourhood with digital technology at its core.

Ms. Lysyk's report echoed many of these criticisms and offered more. It made public for the first time concerns among her office, government officials and Waterfront Toronto directors that insufficient timelines were provided to sign off on the project, and how bidders were treated.

She recommended further government study and oversight of the project; at present, the three levels of government each nominate members to its board. She also suggested the province do its own public consultations and set up an advisory council to design future policies to govern the complex, data-driven world of smart cities.

The report appeased some of Quayside's most vocal critics, including Jim Balsillie, the former Research in Motion (now BlackBerry) co-chief executive who chairs the Council of Canadian Innovators. "I welcome the scrutiny about their reckless smart-city charade," he told The Globe. Julie Di Lorenzo, who left Waterfront Toronto's board last summer over concerns about Quayside, said that she was "pleased that some transparency has been provided to the taxpayer and residents."

In a phone interview, numerous Waterfront Toronto executives said that while they welcomed the report, they believed it misconstrued some details, including project timelines and the allegation of preferential treatment for Sidewalk. "We stand behind the process" that Waterfront Toronto has so far undertaken, said Michael Nobrega, the agency's acting CEO.

The agency also provided a letter from former Ontario associate chief justice Coulter Osborne, who sometimes acts as a "fairness adviser" in procurement disputes, that said the process "proceeded on the basis that no proponent or potential proponent secured any unfair advantage."

According to the report, in June, 2016 - more than a year before the announcement and months before the Quayside project went out for a formal requestfor-proposals (RFP) - Waterfront Toronto's chief planner wrote in an e-mail to Sidewalk chief executive officer Dan Doctoroff that "My new CEO [William Fleissig] and I are very interested in what you are doing at Google and would like to talk to you about a potential pilot in Toronto."

This e-mail was part of a broader consultation process exploring the "potential for innovation" at the Quayside lands, but kicked off the chain of events that would eventually lead to Waterfront Toronto awarding the massive project to Sidewalk. Before the RFP was publicized, the agency provided information and site tours to Sidewalk - and while other potential bidders received similar treatment, Ms. Lysyk wrote in her report that "Sidewalk Labs received more information from Waterfront Toronto prior to the RFP than other parties. ... This raises the risk of an unfair and unequal advantage to all parties that would be responding to the RFP."

Both Sidewalk and Waterfront Toronto pointed to Mr. Osborne's letter to refute those statements.

Meanwhile, Waterfront Toronto's then-CEO Mr. Fleissig, who resigned this past summer, said a concern that would become a key theme for critics this year. In an internal e-mail from July, 2016, he wrote that Sidewalk, which he referred to as sister company Google, "has purportedly told other candidate communities that they want to control ALL data in this demonstration project area.

Could present privacy issues and control issues."

Micah Lasher, Sidewalk's policy head, refuted Mr. Fleissig's comments. "That is not now, and never has been the case," he said, arguing that the company had long floated the idea of housing data in a public trust, which it formally proposed in October.

Ms. Lysyk also wrote that the six weeks provided for companies such as Sidewalk to respond to the RFP in early 2017 was insufficient both in her eyes - given that other projects gave respondents 10 weeks or more - as well as in the eyes of unsuccessful bidders that her office interviewed.

After Waterfront Toronto selected Sidewalk as its winner, a threemember committee of the board saw the draft terms of what would become the project's initial agreement, and met with management to discuss it over the next month; that committee could not reach a consensus about whether it would support the project.

But Waterfront Toronto pressed on. Mr. Fleissig presented the initial agreement to the board on Friday, Oct. 13, after just two briefings. According to internal emails reviewed by the auditorgeneral's office, "the Board felt it was being 'urged - strongly' by the federal and provincial governments" to approve the deal.

Still, the board signed the initial agreement the following Monday, Oct. 16 - with just one business day to review it - despite the fact that Waterfront Toronto "did not adequately consult" multiple federal and provincial ministries and city departments, the report says. And just a day later, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, then-premier Kathleen Wynne and Toronto Mayor John Tory showed up to an event announcing the deal with Sidewalk Labs, with then-Alphabet executive chairman Eric Schmidt.

Associated Graphic

Sidewalk Labs employee Jesse Shapins takes questions at a public forum concerning development on Toronto's waterfront in August. The Waterfront Toronto group awarded a massive smart-city project to Sidewalk Labs, but Ontario Auditor-General Bonnie Lysyk says the project needs more oversight.

ROB GILLIES/AP


Huh? How did I get here?
Return to Main Hugh_Winsor Page
Subscribe to
The Globe and Mail
 

Email this article Print this article

space  Advertisement
space

Need CPR for your RSP? Check your portfolio’s pulse and lower yours by improving the overall health of your investments. Click here.

Advertisement

7-Day Site Search
    

Breaking News



Today's Weather


Inside

Rick Salutin
Merrily marching
off to war
Roy MacGregor
Duct tape might hold
when panic strikes


Editorial
Where Manley is going with his first budget




space

Columnists



For a columnist's most recent stories, click on their name below.

 National


Roy MacGregor arrow
This Country
space
Jeffrey Simpson arrow
The Nation
space
Margaret Wente arrow
Counterpoint
space
Hugh Winsor  arrow
The Power Game
space
 Business


Rob Carrick arrow
Personal Finance
space
Drew Fagan arrow
The Big Picture
space
Mathew Ingram arrow
space
Brent Jang arrow
Business West
space
Brian Milner arrow
Taking Stock
space
Eric Reguly arrow
To The Point
space
Andrew Willis arrow
Streetwise
space
 Sports


Stephen Brunt arrow
The Game
space
Eric Duhatschek arrow
space
Allan Maki arrow
space
William Houston arrow
Truth & Rumours
space
Lorne Rubenstein arrow
Golf
space
 The Arts


John Doyle arrow
Television
space
John MacLachlan Gray arrow
Gray's Anatomy
space
David Macfarlane arrow
Cheap Seats
space
Johanna Schneller arrow
Moviegoer
space
 Comment


Murray Campbell arrow
Ontario Politics
space
Lysiane Gagnon arrow
Inside Quebec
space
Marcus Gee arrow
The World
space
William Johnson arrow
Pit Bill
space
Paul Knox arrow
Worldbeat
space
Heather Mallick arrow
As If
space
Leah McLaren arrow
Generation Why
space
Rex Murphy arrow
Japes of Wrath
space
Rick Salutin arrow
On The Other Hand
space
Paul Sullivan arrow
The West
space
William Thorsell arrow
space





Home | Business | National | Int'l | Sports | Columnists | The Arts | Tech | Travel | TV | Wheels
space

© 2003 Bell Globemedia Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Help & Contact Us | Back to the top of this page