In her book, Coaching, Counseling & Mentoring: How to Choose & Use the Right
Technique to Boost Employee Performance, author Florence M. Stone states that as a
mentor, “your focus is to share your experience, wisdom and political savvy to enable
your top performers to take on tasks beyond those designated in their job descriptions”.
Sounds like a tall order – both for the mentor and the protégé!
Maybe so, but the reality is that mentoring relationships and programs can work, and
they can work extremely well when done properly. Mentoring is a relationship – it is a
two-way partnership characterized by commitment, knowledge-sharing and positive
results. Mentoring can help a protégé get on the path to success and remain loyal to an
employer, while helping a mentor gain valuable leadership experience. The opportunity
can also give a superstar an intangible reward in place of a promotion or raise in the
event of a career plateau.
Whether you're seeking to shape future leaders, provide career-building or managerial
opportunities, or leverage the experience and expertise of senior-level staff before they
opt for retirement, mentoring can strengthen skills within your organizational and provide
an excellent boost to people performance.
Informal vs Formal Mentoring Programs
Mentoring can be informal, where a protégé and mentor select each other on their own
terms. Since people often choose a partner who shares similar career aspirations and
personality style, these relationships have a good chance of working out well because
the two people are a natural match. The relationship will typically evolve over time, and
doesn't necessarily have a set structure that outlines the activities, goals and outcomes
that are to be achieved. Personally, I have witnessed greater success in informal
mentoring than in formal programs. This is no way indicates that a formal program isn't
worth pursuing as long as the significant pre-work required to ensure its success is
completed.
In a formal mentoring program, protégés and mentors are carefully selected and
paired based on organizational needs including succession planning, and best-practice
programs include critical professional development, training, learning, advocacy and
professional experiences. Setting up this type of initiative typically requires executivelevel
sponsorship and involves the work of the Human Resources department and a
dedicated coordinator. There is a structured course of action, a discussion of
expectations, goal-setting, determination of schedules that work for both people, and
evaluation of outcomes.
Before any formal mentoring program is contemplated, a full-scale organizational
assessment should be conducted to ensure the program would be successful. Is the
company receptive to it, and will the initiative be supported once it’s off the ground?
What will be the benefits to the company? What are the goals of the program? How will
the organization measure if the goals are accomplished? How will the program support
the company's vision, strategies and financial mission? How will you choose mentors
and mentees? Who will be responsible for the day-to-day operations? Developing a fullscale
proposal will help to answer these questions up front.
A Must: Selecting the Right Mentors & Mentees
Informal or formal, the mentoring relationship can only be successful when the
individuals are well-suited. On the mentee side of the relationship, the protégé must put
forth an effort to maintain the professional tie, including eagerness and a receptiveness
to being coached. Traits of a successful protégé include:
• Positive attitude
• Desire to advance career
• Commitment to mentoring relationship
• Willingness to take initiative
• Openness and responsiveness to feedback
What makes an excellent mentor? The mentor’s job is to coach, facilitate, counsel and
network to help the protégé advance their professional skills. Not everyone is cut out to
serve in this capacity. Traits of a successful mentor include:
- Extensive knowledge of the profession
- Strong leadership skills
- Willingness to be responsible for someone else's growth and advancement
- Well-networked within the professional community
- Ability to communicate with protégé in an open and honest manner about
development needs and performance.
According to Stone, qualified mentors are also role models, coaches, brokers,
advocates and career counsellors.
- Role model: The mentor has reached a level of accomplishment in a role that
the protégé aspires to, and typically possesses qualities and attributes that the
mentee wishes to acquire. It is that person’s behaviour that people will watch and
try to emulate, and their leadership qualities that people will want to duplicate.
Mentors should ask themselves the following questions:
- Do I act in ways that are ethical, earning the trust of others?
- Do my remarks show consideration for the feelings and convictions of
others?
- Do I keep my commitments?
- Can I be trusted to keep information in confidence?
- Do I have the strength of character to be the bearer of bad news when
that is my responsibility?
- Coach: According to Stone, coaching can boost the performance of workers by
“making clear to them what they should do and how they should best do it (think
instruction), positively reinforce good work (think praise), and find ways to
redesign jobs or increase employee contribution (think empowerment or shared
leadership).” As a mentor, coaching involves providing frequent, honest feedback
that will help mentees flourish and improve their skills. This could also involve
career counselling.
- Broker: Mentors should have solid business contacts through which they can
help to increase the mentee’s profile within the business or the industry
community. Mentors should also be able to consult with a list of skilled individuals
to help the mentee in their respective areas of expertise.
- Advocate: As advocates, mentors are cheerleaders, offering positive feedback
to their mentees about their work and helping to ensure they are given the
chance to spread their wings. The recommendation of a mentee to other
business contacts should be trustworthy and valuable.
With the right match-up of people, both mentors and mentees can come out of the
relationship with increased confidence, greater awareness of the company's corporate
culture and a better understanding of their desired career paths.
This article first appeared in Ceridian Canada’s e-newsletter, The Specialist, January 2007
issue.
Untitled
Ceridian delivers best-practice Human Resource solutions to help customers acquire the best talent, pay their staff accurately and on time, improve HR decision-making and reporting, and drive employee engagement and wellbeing.
To learn more about our suite of HR solutions and how we can partner with your organization, click here or call us toll-free at 1-877-CERIDIAN.
© Ceridian Corporation. All rights reserved.